Claire, a 48-year-old, 200-pound nurse whom I’ve known for many years, recently showed me her computerized “diet database.”
“Look at this, Dr. Fox,” she said proudly, pointing to the computer screen. “Here’s a list of the diets I’ve been on, arranged alphabetically.” It looked like there were 30 or 40 diets on the screen, from Atkins down to Zone.
New words and numbers appeared on the screen moments after she tapped a few keys on the keyboard. “Now they’re arranged by pounds lost. See?” She pointed to the first item on the list.
“I lost 50 pounds on liquid protein, that’s the most, then 42 pounds when my jaw was wired and 28 pounds on this fruit only diet. And look at this.”
The display changed as she tapped a few more keys. “Now I’ve got them listed by amounts of weight regained after going off the diet. And the list in this column shows the side effects of each diet.” She sat back in her chair, smiling proudly. “This is the most complete record of dieting ever compiled. By name, by dates that I was on the diet, by pounds lost, pounds gained, side effects, and cost; I’ve got it all.” Her smile faded as she continued. “Unfortunately, I’ve also still got all the fat I started with.” Claire is not alone. One out of every three American adults is obese1 and millions more are carrying around too much fat and becoming obese. Despite the fitness craze that arose in the 1970s and still continues, America is not a slim and healthy nation. But we certainly want to be (and quickly), so we turn to fad diets.
In the early years of my practice of internal medicine and cardiology, I put many people on weight-loss diets in an attempt to improve their health. But things did not go nearly as well as I had hoped. In fact, I once joked to a colleague, “I think I’m running a weight gain practice.” Many of my patients were actually getting heavier on the unimpressive diets we doctors used to recommend back in the 1950s and 1960s.
In the 40 years I’ve practiced medicine, I’ve seen every kind of diet you can imagine: water diets, grapefruit diets, the Drinking Man’s Diet, the Stillman and Atkins diets, pineapple diets, starvation diets, no-carbohydrate diets, starch-blocking diets, diets with pills, diets without pills, “scientific” diets, “common sense” diets, army diets, air force diets, American diets, foreign diets, liquid diets, and liquid protein diets. I learned about these diets from my colleagues, from the medical literature, from my patients, from my secretary, from my wife, even from Reader’s Digest and The Ladies’ Home Journal.
My patients have always asked me which diet was the best, which one they should be on. I knew you could lose a lot of
weight quickly on almost any of the diets, but I always hesitated to recommend one. Once I was approached by a manufacturer of the supplement used in the
Starch-Blocker Diet, who asked me to say something positive about the pill. As I spoke with the manufacturer, I realized that he didn’t know how much trouble this starch-blocking supplement could create as it blocked the ability of the pancreas to make an enzyme called amylase. Sure enough, many people who went on this diet suffered from nausea, vomiting, and other problems. The moral of the story is you must learn everything you can about a diet or supplement before you take it, and avoid it if the answers are not positive.
The problem with most all the fad diets is they are ill conceived, ineffective in the long run, and often dangerous. The originators and purveyors of these diets do
not understand (or have chosen to ignore) the underlying meaning and rationale of diets. Most of us think of a diet as a quick way to lose weight. We see it as a temporary device, a way to control ourselves or juggle food around. And once we’ve lost the desired amount of weight, we quickly and happily discard it.
The word “diet” comes from the Greek word “diaita,” which means a mode of life or a regimen. A diet, then, is not a temporary aid to be dropped and forgotten when the weight-loss goal is met. Instead, it is a lifelong plan, a blueprint for your life and health.
You can lose weight (at least temporarily) on just about any diet. But before you do, ask yourself 2 very important questions: How are you losing the weight? And how will the process affect your health?
There are three ways to lose weight: 1) By getting rid of water in your tissues; 2) By forcing your body to consume lean body tissue such as the heart, lungs, kidneys, or muscles; or 3) By burning fatty tissue.
Losing water weight, as you do with the high-protein diets and diuretics, is absolutely worthless because you will quickly replace the lost water and find yourself right back where you started. Losing and regaining water is not only a big waste of time and money, but it can also cause you to lose vital minerals, which can prompt serious medical problems.
Cutting into your lean body tissue is also a dangerous, possibly deadly, approach. Vital organs can become undermined, leading to organ damage and even organ failure. The only safe, sound, and permanent weight-loss method is burning off excess fat. Doing so takes time and patience, but fad diet promoters would rather promise quick and easy weight loss. Unfortunately, their promises are usually just hot air. Numerous studies have shown that 95 percent of those who lose 30 to 40 pounds or more on fad diets will gain it all back (often with interest) within 1 year. And 99 percent will have gained back all the lost weight within 3 years.
*52\29\2*